The Amazon credit card makes sense only if you spend enough on Amazon to offset the annual fee

Amazon offers two credit cards: the Amazon Prime Rewards Visa Signature Card (which requires a Prime membership) and the Amazon Rewards Visa Card (no membership required). Both earn cash back on Amazon purchases, but the Prime version costs $0 annually and earns 5% back on Amazon.com and Whole Foods purchases if you're a Prime member. The non-Prime version costs nothing and earns 3% back on Amazon purchases. The real question is whether the rewards you earn exceed what you'd pay in fees and whether you'd use the card enough to make it worthwhile.

The card is worth carrying if you spend at least $500 per month on Amazon and Whole Foods combined. Below that threshold, the rewards don't offset the opportunity cost of carrying another card and managing another account. Above that threshold, the 5% cash back on Prime purchases adds up quickly—$600 per year in rewards on $12,000 in annual spending.

Key Takeaways

  • The Amazon Prime Rewards card has no annual fee but requires an active Prime membership, which costs $139 per year or $14.99 per month.
  • You earn 5% cash back on Amazon.com and Whole Foods purchases with the Prime card, but only 1% on everything else, making it a narrow-use card.
  • The non-Prime Amazon Rewards card has no annual fee and no membership requirement, but earns only 3% back on Amazon purchases and 1% everywhere else.
  • The card is worth using only if your monthly Amazon and Whole Foods spending is high enough that the rewards exceed the cost of Prime membership.
  • Both cards charge no foreign transaction fees and offer purchase protection, but these benefits are standard on most premium cards.

How the Prime card's rewards actually work

The Amazon Prime Rewards Visa Signature Card earns 5% cash back on Amazon.com and Whole Foods Market purchases, 2% at restaurants, gas stations, and drugstores, and 1% on everything else. The cash back posts to your Amazon account as a statement credit and can be used when ready on your next purchase. You don't have to wait for a check or transfer the money yourself.

The catch is that the 5% rate only applies if you have an active Prime membership. Prime costs $139 per year (or $14.99 per month if you pay monthly). That means you need to earn at least $139 in cash back annually just to break even on the membership cost. At 5% back, that requires $2,780 in annual Amazon and Whole Foods spending, or about $232 per month. If you spend less than that, the card costs you money compared to using a no-fee card with lower rewards.

The 2% back at restaurants, gas, and drugstores is useful but not exceptional—many general-purpose cards offer 2% back on all purchases. The 1% on everything else is below average for a card with no annual fee.

When the non-Prime card makes more sense

The Amazon Rewards Visa Card (without Prime) has no annual fee and no membership requirement. It earns 3% cash back on Amazon.com purchases and 1% on everything else. This card is worth considering if you shop on Amazon regularly but don't have Prime or don't want to pay for it.

The 3% rate is lower than the Prime card's 5%, but you save $139 per year in membership fees. You break even compared to the Prime card if you spend less than $2,780 per year on Amazon—or about $232 per month. Below that threshold, the non-Prime card is the better choice. Above it, the Prime card's 5% rate wins out.

The 1% cash back on non-Amazon purchases is weak. If you use this card for groceries, gas, or dining, you're leaving money on the table compared to cards that offer 2% or higher on those categories. This card works best as a single-purpose Amazon card, not as your everyday card.

What you're paying in opportunity cost

The real cost of the Amazon card isn't the annual fee—it's the rewards you miss by not using a better card for non-Amazon purchases. If you spend $1,000 per month on groceries, gas, and dining, a card that earns 2% on those categories would give you $240 per year in rewards. The Amazon card's 1% rate would give you $120 per year. That's a $120 annual loss, even though the card itself is free.

The same logic applies to the Prime card. Yes, you earn 5% on Amazon, but you're earning only 1% on everything else while paying $139 per year for Prime. If you use the card for everyday purchases, you're subsidizing your Amazon rewards with worse rewards on the rest of your spending. The card only makes financial sense if you use it almost exclusively for Amazon and Whole Foods, and use a different card for everything else.

This is why the Amazon card works best as a second card, not your primary card. Carry it for Amazon purchases, and use a 2% flat-rate card or a category-focused card for everything else.

The benefits that don't move the needle

Both Amazon cards offer purchase protection, extended warranty coverage, and no foreign transaction fees. These are real benefits, but they're standard on most Visa Signature cards and many mid-tier rewards cards. They don't justify carrying the card on their own.

The Prime card also includes roadside information and emergency medical and dental services while traveling. Again, these are nice to have but not unique. If you're choosing between this card and another card based on these perks, you're making the decision on the wrong factors. The math on the rewards is what matters.

The math: Does it pencil out for you?

Use this table to figure out whether the Prime card or the non-Prime card makes sense for your spending:

Annual Amazon + Whole Foods SpendingPrime Card Annual RewardsPrime Card Net Cost (after $139 membership)Non-Prime Card Annual Rewards
$1,000$50-$89$30
$3,000$150+$11$90
$5,000$250+$111$150
$10,000$500+$361$300

The table assumes you earn only the 5% or 3% rate on Amazon and Whole Foods, and 1% on everything else (which you shouldn't use the card for). If you spend less than $2,780 per year on Amazon and Whole Foods, the non-Prime card is the better choice. If you spend more than that and have Prime for other reasons, the Prime card wins. If you spend less than $500 per year on Amazon, neither card is worth the mental overhead of carrying it.

Better alternatives depending on your spending

If you spend heavily on Amazon but don't have Prime, the non-Prime Amazon card is a reasonable choice. If you have Prime and spend $3,000+ per year on Amazon and Whole Foods, the Prime card's 5% rate is hard to beat for those specific purchases.

But if you're looking for a general-purpose rewards card, there are better options. The Chase Freedom Unlimited earns 1.5% on all purchases with no annual fee and no membership requirement. The Capital One SavorOne earns 3% on dining, entertainment, and streaming, and 1% on everything else, also with no annual fee. The Citi Double Cash earns 2% on all purchases (1% when you buy, 1% when you pay the bill). None of these cards tie you to a single retailer or require a membership fee.

The Amazon card is best used as a second card: carry it for Amazon purchases, and use a flat-rate or category card for everything else. If you're trying to pick one card to do everything, the Amazon card is too narrow.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need Prime to get the Amazon credit card?

No. Amazon offers two versions: the Prime Rewards card (which requires Prime membership) and the standard Amazon Rewards card (which does not). The Prime card earns 5% back on Amazon purchases but costs $139 per year for membership. The non-Prime card earns 3% back on Amazon purchases and has no membership fee.

Can I use the rewards on anything other than Amazon?

No. The cash back posts as an Amazon account credit and can only be used to pay for purchases on Amazon.com or Whole Foods (for the Prime card). You cannot transfer the rewards to another account or redeem them for cash. This is a significant limitation compared to cards that let you use rewards anywhere.

What happens to my rewards if I cancel Prime?

Your existing cash back rewards stay in your Amazon account and can still be used. However, you will no longer earn the 5% rate on new purchases—you'll drop to 3% on Amazon purchases and 1% on everything else. If you're canceling Prime because you don't shop on Amazon enough, the card becomes much less valuable.

Is the Amazon card better than a general rewards card?

Only if you spend enough on Amazon to offset the Prime membership cost (about $232 per month) and you use a different card for non-Amazon purchases. If you're looking for one card to use everywhere, a flat-rate 2% card or a category card will give you better rewards on most of your spending.

Does the card have an annual fee?

No. Both the Prime and non-Prime versions have no annual fee. The Prime card's cost comes from the $139 annual Prime membership, not from the card itself. If you already have Prime for shipping and video, the card adds no additional cost.