The Amazon card makes sense if you spend regularly on Amazon and at Whole Foods, but costs you nothing if you don't use it

Amazon offers two credit cards: the Amazon Prime Rewards Visa Signature Card and the Amazon Prime Store Card. The Visa Signature card earns 5% cash back on Amazon purchases and Whole Foods, 2% at gas stations and restaurants, and 1% elsewhere — but only if you're a Prime member. The Store Card earns 5% on Amazon only and requires no Prime membership, but works nowhere else. Neither card charges an annual fee. The real question is whether the rewards you'd earn outweigh the spending you'd need to do to get them, and whether you'd actually use the card or let it sit in a drawer.

The answer depends on three things: how much you spend on Amazon and Whole Foods each year, whether you're a Prime member, and whether you plan to keep the card open long enough for your credit score to recover from opening it. If your Amazon and Whole Foods spending is under $500 per year, the card won't earn enough to justify the credit inquiry. If it's over $2,000 per year, the card is a clear financial win. In between, the math is close enough that your decision should rest on whether you'll actually use it.

Key Takeaways

  • The Amazon Prime Rewards Visa Signature card earns 5% back on Amazon and Whole Foods purchases, but requires an active Prime membership to set up and use.
  • You need to spend roughly $1,200 per year on Amazon alone to earn back what a typical rewards card costs in annual fees — but Amazon's cards charge no annual fee, so there's no break-even point to reach.
  • The 2% cash back at gas stations and restaurants is lower than what competing cards offer, so the card only wins if Amazon and Whole Foods make up most of your spending.
  • Cash back posts as a statement credit, not as a separate deposit, so you must check your statement to confirm the reward arrived.
  • Closing the card after opening it can hurt your credit score by reducing your available credit and shortening your credit history, so keep it open for at least two years.

How the rewards actually work

The Amazon Prime Rewards Visa Signature card deposits cash back as a statement credit once per month. You don't receive it as a separate payment or deposit — it straightforward reduces your balance. This means you need to monitor your statement to confirm the reward posted, because it won't show up as a separate transaction in your bank account. If a month passes and you don't see the reward, contact Amazon's customer service to track it down.

The 5% rate on Amazon purchases applies to Amazon.com and Amazon Fresh, but not to third-party sellers using Amazon's marketplace. If you buy from a seller who uses Amazon's fulfillment network, you still get 5% — the distinction is whether Amazon itself is the seller of record. Whole Foods purchases earn 5% whether you use a card in-store or link your Prime account to the register. The 2% category at gas stations and restaurants is narrower than it sounds. It covers gas pumps and restaurants only, not convenience stores or fast-food chains that don't classify as restaurants. If you're comparing this card to a flat 2% cash back card, the Amazon card loses money on non-Amazon spending.

When the card actually saves you money

The card saves money only if Amazon and Whole Foods purchases make up a meaningful share of your annual spending. If you spend $3,000 per year on Amazon and $1,000 at Whole Foods, you earn $200 in cash back (5% of $4,000). That's real money. If you spend $500 per year on Amazon and $200 at Whole Foods, you earn $35 — which is real but small. The card loses value if you're comparing it to a flat-rate card. A card that earns 2% cash back on all purchases will beat the Amazon card on gas and restaurant spending, and tie it on everything else.

The Amazon card only wins if you're willing to carry two cards and use each for its category, or if Amazon and Whole Foods truly dominate your budget. The card also loses value if you're not a Prime member. The Visa Signature card requires an active Prime membership to open and to earn the 5% rate. If you cancel Prime, the card still works, but it drops to 1% cash back on Amazon — making it worse than a flat-rate card. The Store Card has no Prime requirement, but it earns 5% on Amazon only, so it's useful only if Amazon is nearly all of your spending.

The hidden cost of opening a card you might not use

Opening a credit card affects your credit score in two ways. Your score drops slightly when the card issuer checks your credit (a hard inquiry), and it drops again when the new account lowers your average account age. These effects fade over time, but they're real in the short term. The bigger cost comes if you open the card for a bonus offer and then close it. Closing a card removes it from your available credit, which can raise your credit utilization ratio — the percentage of your total credit limit that you're using.

A higher utilization ratio lowers your score. Closing the card also removes its age from your credit history, which can lower your average account age and hurt your score further. If you open the card and close it within a year, you may see a score drop of 10 to 50 points depending on your overall credit profile. If you open the card and keep it open but unused, the damage is minimal. Your score recovers from the hard inquiry and new account within a few months. The card itself helps your score by adding available credit and aging over time.

Comparing the Amazon card to other rewards cards

The Chase Sapphire Preferred earns 3% on dining and travel, 2% on groceries and gas, and 1% elsewhere. It charges $95 per year, so you need to earn at least $95 in rewards to break even. The Amazon card charges nothing, so it wins on cost. But the Sapphire Preferred wins on flexibility — it covers more categories and earns higher rates on dining and travel. The Capital One SavorOne earns 3% on dining, entertainment, and groceries, and 1% elsewhere. It charges no annual fee, like the Amazon card. If you spend heavily on groceries and dining, the SavorOne will earn more than the Amazon card. If you spend heavily on Amazon and Whole Foods, the Amazon card will earn more.

The Citi Double Cash earns 2% cash back on all purchases with no annual fee. It's the simplest comparison: if your Amazon and Whole Foods spending is less than 40% of your total spending, the Double Cash will earn more. If it's more than 40%, the Amazon card will earn more. The choice between these cards comes down to where you actually spend money. If you're a Prime member who buys groceries at Whole Foods and orders from Amazon regularly, the Amazon card is hard to beat. If you eat out often and travel, the Sapphire Preferred or SavorOne may serve you better.

What happens if you get a sign-up bonus

Amazon occasionally offers sign-up bonuses on its cards — typically $100 to $150 in statement credits after you spend a certain amount in the first few months. These bonuses are real money, but they come with a trap: they encourage you to open a card you might not otherwise use. If you open the card for a $100 bonus and then close it, you've earned $100 but paid for it with a credit score drop. If your score was already lower than 700, that drop could cost you hundreds of dollars in higher interest rates on a future mortgage or car loan.

If your score is above 750, the damage is smaller but still real. The bonus makes sense only if you plan to keep the card open and use it regularly. If you're opening it purely for the bonus, calculate whether the bonus is worth the score hit. For most people, it's not. A better approach is to open the card only if you'd use it anyway, and treat any bonus as a bonus rather than the reason to open it.

How to decide if you should open this card

Start by adding up your annual spending on Amazon and Whole Foods. If it's less than $500 per year, the card won't earn enough to justify the credit inquiry. If it's between $500 and $2,000 per year, the card is worth opening and keeping open, but the rewards are modest. If it's more than $2,000 per year, the card is a clear win. Next, check whether you're a Prime member. If you're not, the Visa Signature card won't work for you — the Store Card is your only option, and it only earns 5% on Amazon. If you're a Prime member but considering canceling, remember that the card's value drops to 1% cash back if you do.

Finally, commit to keeping the card open for at least two years. This gives your credit score time to recover from the hard inquiry and new account, and it lets the account age and help your score. If you think you'll close it within a year, don't open it. The rewards you'd earn won't be worth the credit score damage.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the Amazon card work at other retailers that sell Amazon products?

No. The 5% rate applies only to Amazon.com, Amazon Fresh, and Whole Foods. Retailers like Target or Walmart that sell Amazon products don't earn the higher rate. You earn 1% cash back on those purchases unless they fall into another category, like gas or restaurants.

Can I use the Amazon Prime Store Card if I don't have Prime?

Yes. The Store Card has no Prime requirement. It earns 5% cash back on Amazon purchases and 1% elsewhere. It doesn't work at Whole Foods or earn higher rates at gas stations and restaurants, so it's useful only if Amazon is most of your spending.

What happens to my rewards if I close the card?

Any cash back you've already earned stays on your account as a statement credit. You can use it to pay down your balance. Future purchases won't earn rewards once the card is closed, but existing rewards don't disappear.

Does the Amazon card offer purchase protection or travel insurance?

The Visa Signature card includes purchase protection, extended warranty coverage, and travel accident insurance. The Store Card includes purchase protection only. These benefits are standard for Visa Signature cards and can add value, but they're not unique to the Amazon card.

How long does cash back take to appear on my statement?

Cash back posts once per month, usually within a few days of the end of the billing cycle. Check your statement to confirm it arrived — don't assume it posted automatically. If a month passes and you don't see the reward, contact Amazon's customer service to track it down.