What happens when you dispute a charge
When you dispute a charge on your credit card, you are telling your card issuer that a transaction is wrong — either because you did not make it, the merchant charged you twice, the amount is incorrect, or the goods or services were never delivered. Your card issuer then investigates by asking the merchant for proof that the charge was legitimate. During the investigation, the issuer may refund the amount to your account temporarily while they gather evidence.
The process is not instantaneous. Most disputes take 30 to 90 days to resolve, though your card issuer must acknowledge your dispute within 30 days and complete the investigation within 60 days. If the merchant cannot prove the charge was correct, you keep the refund. If they provide evidence that the charge was valid, the money goes back to them and you owe it again.
Disputing a charge does not hurt your credit score directly, but it does create a record with your card issuer. If you dispute many charges, the issuer may close your account or decline to renew it, viewing the pattern as a sign of risk.
Key Takeaways
- You must contact your card issuer, not the merchant, to start a dispute — call the number on the back of your card or log into your online account.
- Disputes must be filed within 60 days of the charge appearing on your statement, so act quickly if you spot an error.
- Your card issuer will likely refund the amount while investigating, but you may owe it back if the merchant proves the charge was correct.
- Gather any evidence you have before you file — emails, receipts, delivery confirmations, or proof that you cancelled a subscription.
When to dispute instead of asking the merchant
If you can resolve the problem directly with the merchant, that is usually faster than a dispute. Contact them first if the charge is small, recent, or clearly a mistake on their end — a duplicate charge, a wrong amount, or an item that was never shipped. Many merchants will refund you within days if you have proof.
File a dispute with your card issuer instead if the merchant is unresponsive, refuses to refund you, or has closed. Also dispute if you did not make the charge at all — this is fraud, and your card issuer has a legal obligation to investigate. Do not wait for the merchant to respond if you believe your card information was stolen.
If you cancelled a subscription but were charged again, try the merchant first, but be ready to dispute if they claim you still owe it. The same applies to charges from a business that has shut down — the merchant cannot help you, so the dispute is your only path.
How to file a dispute with your card issuer
Start by calling the customer service number on the back of your credit card. Tell them you want to dispute a charge and have your statement ready so you can give them the transaction date, merchant name, and amount. Some card issuers also let you file a dispute through their website or mobile app — log in, find the transaction, and select "dispute this charge" or similar language.
When you explain the dispute, be specific about what went wrong. Do not say "I do not recognize this charge" if you actually do recognize it but think the amount is wrong — that triggers a fraud investigation instead of a billing error investigation, and the process is different. If the merchant charged you twice, say that. If they charged you for something you returned, say that. If the item never arrived, say that.
The issuer will assign your dispute a reference number. Write it down. You may be asked to sign a statement swearing that the charge is wrong — this is normal and protects you legally. Some issuers mail this form; others handle it over the phone.
What evidence helps your case
Gather anything that supports your version of events before you file. If the merchant charged you twice, show your statement with both charges. If you returned an item, find the return receipt or tracking number showing it was delivered back to the merchant. If you cancelled a subscription, save the email confirmation. If the item never arrived, pull up the tracking information showing it was not delivered to your address.
For fraud disputes, you do not need to prove you did not make the charge — your card issuer must prove you did. But if you can show you were somewhere else when the charge happened, or that your card was in your possession, that strengthens your case. A police report for stolen card information also helps, though it is not required.
If the merchant promised something in writing — an email saying the item would arrive by a certain date, or a screenshot of the price before checkout — save that too. The issuer will ask the merchant for their side of the story, and your evidence makes it harder for them to claim something different happened.
What happens during the investigation
Once you file, your card issuer contacts the merchant and asks them to prove the charge was correct. The merchant has a set time — usually 7 to 10 days — to respond with evidence. This might be a signed receipt, a delivery confirmation, or proof that you received the goods or services.
While the investigation is ongoing, your card issuer will usually credit the disputed amount back to your account temporarily. This does not mean you have won — it means the issuer is giving you the benefit of the doubt while they investigate. You can spend this money, but if the merchant provides proof and wins the dispute, the amount will be deducted from your account again.
If the merchant does not respond within the time limit, you win by default. If they respond but their evidence is weak or does not match your statement, the issuer may rule in your favor. If their evidence is solid, the issuer will side with them and you will owe the charge.
What to do if you lose the dispute
If your card issuer rules against you, the refund is removed from your account and the charge stands. You have the right to request that the issuer review their decision, but this is rarely successful unless you have new evidence you did not provide the first time.
At this point, your options are limited. If you still believe the charge is wrong, you can file a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) at consumerfinance.gov. The CFPB does not overturn the issuer's decision, but they investigate whether the issuer followed the law correctly. If the issuer made a procedural error — for example, if they did not acknowledge your dispute within 30 days — the CFPB can order them to correct it.
You can also pursue the merchant directly through small claims court if the amount is large enough to justify the effort. This is separate from the credit card dispute and requires you to prove your case to a judge, but it may be worth it if the merchant owes you hundreds of dollars.
How disputes affect your credit and account
A single dispute does not damage your credit score. The dispute itself is not reported to the credit bureaus, and winning or losing a dispute does not change your credit history. However, if you dispute many charges over time, your card issuer may view you as a high-risk customer and close your account or refuse to renew it.
While a dispute is pending, the charge still appears on your statement, but it is usually marked as "disputed" or "under investigation." This does not affect your credit utilization or your payment history — the issuer knows the charge is contested.
If you lose a dispute and refuse to pay, the charge becomes a regular debt. If you do not pay it, the issuer can report it to the credit bureaus as a late payment, which will hurt your score. Paying the charge after losing a dispute prevents this damage.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I dispute a charge after more than 60 days?
No. Your card issuer is only required to investigate disputes filed within 60 days of the charge appearing on your statement. If you wait longer, they can refuse to open a dispute. Mark your calendar when you spot a problem and contact your issuer right away.
What if the merchant says I signed for the charge?
A signature does not automatically mean you authorized the charge — it means the merchant has proof you received the goods or services. If you dispute because the item was defective or never arrived, the signature does not help the merchant. If you dispute because you did not make the purchase at all, a signature is stronger evidence for them, but your issuer will still investigate.
Do I have to pay the charge while the dispute is being investigated?
No. Your card issuer must not report the disputed amount as late while the investigation is pending. However, if you lose the dispute, the charge becomes due again and you must pay it to avoid late fees and credit damage.
Can I dispute a charge if I used a debit card instead of a credit card?
Yes, but the process is different and you have less protection. Debit card disputes are governed by different rules, and your bank has fewer days to investigate. Contact your bank when ready if you spot a fraudulent debit card charge, because the window to dispute is shorter than with credit cards.
What if the merchant goes out of business before the dispute is resolved?
Your dispute continues even if the merchant closes. Your card issuer will attempt to contact them, and if they cannot, the investigation may be resolved in your favor by default. The issuer may also work with the merchant's payment processor or bank to recover the funds.