The Durbin Amendment caps the fees banks charge retailers when you swipe your debit card, but it does not directly change your credit card

The Durbin Amendment, part of the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act, limits what Visa and Mastercard can charge retailers for debit card transactions. Senator Dick Durbin of Illinois sponsored it. The law set a cap on interchange fees — the percentage of each transaction that goes to the card issuer and payment network — and required debit cards to have at least two unaffiliated networks available so retailers could choose the cheaper route.

Credit cards operate under different rules. The Durbin Amendment does not cap credit card interchange fees, which remain negotiated between card networks and banks. This is why your credit card rewards programs have not shrunk the way some debit card benefits did after 2011. Banks still collect enough from credit card transactions to fund cash back, points, and travel perks.

Understanding the Durbin Amendment matters if you use both debit and credit cards, because it explains why your debit card rewards are thinner than your credit card rewards, and why some debit card features disappeared after the law took effect.

Key Takeaways

  • The Durbin Amendment capped debit card interchange fees at roughly 21 cents plus 0.05 percent of the transaction, which reduced bank revenue from debit transactions.
  • Credit card interchange fees were not capped, so issuers still earn enough to fund robust rewards programs on credit cards.
  • Banks responded to lower debit card revenue by cutting debit rewards, adding monthly fees to checking accounts, and raising ATM fees.
  • The amendment required debit cards to route through at least two networks, giving retailers the power to choose the cheaper processing option.

How the Durbin Amendment changed debit card economics

Before 2011, debit card interchange fees varied by bank and card network. Large issuers charged retailers around 1 to 2 percent per transaction. The Durbin Amendment set a hard ceiling: issuers can charge no more than 21 cents plus 0.05 percent of the transaction amount, with some exceptions for smaller banks and fraud prevention costs.

That ceiling meant a $100 debit purchase that once generated $1 to $2 in interchange revenue now generated roughly 26 cents. Banks lost a major income stream. They replaced it by cutting debit card rewards (many debit cards had 1 percent cash back before 2011), introducing monthly checking fees, and raising out-of-network ATM charges. Some banks eliminated free checking entirely for customers who did not meet deposit minimums.

Retailers benefited. Lower processing costs meant they paid less to accept debit cards, though most did not pass savings to customers. The amendment also required debit cards to have at least two unaffiliated networks — typically Visa and Mastercard, or Visa and Star or Pulse — so retailers could route transactions through the cheaper option.

Why credit card rewards stayed strong after Durbin

Credit card interchange fees were explicitly excluded from the Durbin Amendment. Visa and Mastercard still negotiate rates with individual banks, and those rates remain much higher than debit fees — typically 1.5 to 3 percent of the transaction depending on the card type and merchant category.

Higher interchange revenue means issuers can afford to fund credit card rewards. A bank earning $1.50 on a $100 credit purchase can afford to give you 1 percent cash back and still profit. The same bank earning 26 cents on a $100 debit purchase cannot. This is why premium credit cards offer 2 to 5 percent cash back or equivalent points, while debit cards rarely offer more than 0.5 percent.

Retailers have pushed Congress to cap credit card interchange fees as well, but those efforts have not succeeded. Credit card networks argue that higher fees reflect higher fraud risk and the cost of running a more complex system. Debit transactions are simpler and lower-risk, which is why their fees were capped first.

The two-network requirement and what it means for you

The Durbin Amendment required debit cards to carry at least two unaffiliated networks. Before the rule, many debit cards ran only on Visa or Mastercard. Now most run on Visa or Mastercard plus a regional network like Star, Pulse, or Nyce.

Retailers use this choice to reduce costs. When you swipe a debit card, the payment processor can route it through whichever network charges less. You do not choose which network processes your transaction — the retailer does, based on their processing agreement. This routing choice is invisible to you, but it saves retailers money and was the amendment's second major tool for lowering debit card costs.

Credit cards do not have a two-network requirement. Most credit cards run on either Visa or Mastercard exclusively, and some premium cards are issued by American Express or Discover. Retailers cannot choose the network for a credit card transaction the way they can for debit.

Exceptions and special cases in the Durbin Amendment

The 21-cent cap applies to most debit cards, but the law carved out exceptions. Banks with less than $10 billion in assets are exempt from the cap, which is why some community banks and credit unions still offer higher debit rewards. The threshold has not changed since 2010, so as inflation erodes its value, fewer banks may have access to for the exemption.

The amendment also allows issuers to charge extra for fraud prevention and security. Banks can add up to 1 cent per transaction for fraud-related costs, which some do. This brings the practical ceiling to around 22 cents plus 0.05 percent for most large issuers.

Prepaid debit cards and government benefit cards (like unemployment or SNAP cards) have their own rules under Durbin. The cap applies, but the networks and issuers sometimes negotiate different terms for these cards because they serve different populations and have different fraud profiles.

How banks adapted to lower debit revenue

When Durbin took effect in October 2011, banks faced an when ready revenue drop. Debit cards had been a reliable profit center. The response was swift and visible to customers.

Many banks eliminated free checking accounts or added monthly maintenance fees. Others raised overdraft fees, ATM fees, and minimum balance requirements. Some cut debit card rewards to zero. A few banks tried to charge customers a monthly fee just for using a debit card, though public backlash forced most to reverse those plans within weeks.

Banks also shifted marketing toward credit cards, which still generated healthy interchange revenue. This is one reason credit card offers became more aggressive after 2011 — issuers had more incentive to grow credit card volume to replace lost debit revenue.

Durbin and your choice between debit and credit

The amendment does not change how you use your cards, but it explains the economics behind the rewards and fees you see. If you have a credit card with 1.5 percent cash back and a debit card with no rewards, Durbin is a major reason why.

From a rewards perspective, credit cards are almost always better. You earn more cash back or points, and you are not paying for that benefit through lower interchange fees — the retailer is. Debit cards offer no rewards because banks cannot afford to fund them after Durbin capped their revenue.

The tradeoff is that credit cards charge interest if you carry a balance, while debit cards do not. If you cannot pay your credit card bill in full each month, the interest cost will exceed any rewards you earn. In that case, debit is safer even though it pays less.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did the Durbin Amendment affect my credit card rewards?

No. The amendment capped debit card fees only, not credit card fees. Credit card interchange rates remain negotiated between banks and payment networks, so issuers still earn enough to fund rewards programs. Your credit card benefits were not reduced by Durbin.

Can I get a debit card with good rewards?

Most debit cards offer little or no rewards because of the Durbin Amendment's fee cap. Some community banks and credit unions with less than $10 billion in assets are exempt from the cap and may offer higher debit rewards, but these are rare. Credit cards are the standard way to earn rewards.

Why do retailers care about the two-network requirement?

The two-network rule lets retailers choose which network processes a debit transaction, usually based on cost. This gives them negotiating power and saves them money. Credit cards do not have this requirement, so retailers cannot choose the network for credit transactions.

Does the Durbin Amendment explore to online debit transactions?

Yes. The fee cap applies to all debit card transactions, whether in-store, online, or at an ATM. The network choice rule applies to in-store transactions where the retailer can route the card. Online and ATM transactions typically use a single network.

Will the Durbin Amendment ever be changed?

Retailers have pushed Congress to extend the cap to credit cards, and banks have pushed to raise or remove the debit cap. No major changes have passed since 2010. Any change would require new legislation and would likely face opposition from both the banking and retail industries.