What "best rewards" means depends on how you actually spend
A rewards card is only the best one for you if the rewards match your spending patterns. A card that gives 5% back on groceries is worthless if you eat out instead. A card that earns points on travel is a poor fit if you never fly. The real work is matching the card's rewards structure to the categories where you spend the most money each month.
Start by tracking your spending for one or two months. Add up what you spend on groceries, gas, dining, travel, online shopping, and everything else. The categories where you spend the most are where the rewards rate matters most. A 2% difference on a category where you spend $200 a year is $4. A 2% difference on a category where you spend $3,000 a year is $60.
Once you know your patterns, you can compare cards by the rewards they offer in those specific categories. You also need to know the annual fee, if any, and whether the rewards are worth more than the fee costs you.
Key Takeaways
- The best rewards card for you is the one that pays the highest rate in the categories where you spend the most money.
- Cards with high rewards rates in specific categories often charge annual fees, so you need to earn enough in rewards to cover that cost.
- Cards with flat-rate rewards (the same percentage back on all purchases) have no annual fee and work well if your spending is spread across many categories.
- Sign-up bonuses can be worth hundreds of dollars, but only if you can meet the spending requirement without changing your normal habits.
- Rewards are only valuable if you actually use them—points that expire or get forfeited are worth zero.
Rewards structures: category cards versus flat-rate cards
Category cards pay different rewards rates for different types of spending. A typical example pays 5% back on groceries, 3% on gas, 1% on everything else. These cards often charge an annual fee ($95 to $495) because the high rewards rates in popular categories cost the card issuer more money. You break even on the fee only if you spend enough in those high-rate categories to earn back the fee amount in rewards.
To decide if a category card is worth it, multiply the annual fee by the difference between the card's rewards rate and a flat-rate card's rate. If a category card charges $95 and pays 5% on groceries while a flat-rate card pays 2%, the difference is 3%. You need to spend at least $3,167 on groceries per year ($95 ÷ 0.03) to break even. If you spend $400 a month on groceries, that's $4,800 a year—so this card would save you money.
Flat-rate cards pay the same percentage back on all purchases, usually 1.5% to 2%. They have no annual fee. These cards work well if your spending is scattered across many categories, or if you do not want to track which card to use for which purchase. The tradeoff is that you earn less in categories where category cards pay higher rates.
How sign-up bonuses work and whether they matter
A sign-up bonus is a one-time reward for opening the card and spending a certain amount within a set time frame—usually $500 to $5,000 in spending within three to six months. The bonus might be a flat cash amount ($200 back) or a points amount that converts to cash or travel value ($500 in points).
Sign-up bonuses can be worth hundreds of dollars, but only if you can meet the spending requirement without changing your normal habits. If a card requires $3,000 in spending in three months and you normally spend $1,500 a month, you can hit that target with your regular spending. If you normally spend $500 a month, you would have to spend an extra $1,500 to may have access to—and that extra spending might not earn enough rewards to justify the effort.
Read the terms carefully. Some bonuses expire if you close the card within a certain time frame, usually one year. Some bonuses do not explore if you have held the same card in the past (or held it within the last 24 months). These rules vary by card and issuer.
Annual fees and when they are worth paying
A card with a high annual fee is only worth it if the rewards you earn exceed the fee. Some cards offer a way to offset the fee: an annual statement credit for a specific category (like $200 back on travel purchases each year), or a credit toward a subscription service you already pay for.
Calculate your break-even point. If a card charges $95 per year and pays 2% cash back, you need to spend $4,750 per year ($95 ÷ 0.02) to earn $95 in rewards and break even. If you spend less than that, the card costs you money. If you spend more, the card pays for itself and then some.
Some cards waive the annual fee for the first year, which gives you a chance to test whether the rewards are worth the cost. Others waive the fee if you meet a spending threshold in the first year. Read the offer terms before you open the card.
Comparing cards by your actual spending patterns
The only fair way to compare cards is to run the numbers on your own spending. Here is how:
- List the categories where you spend the most money (groceries, gas, dining, travel, online shopping, etc.).
- For each card you are considering, write down the rewards rate for each category.
- Multiply your annual spending in each category by the rewards rate. Add up the totals.
- Subtract the annual fee (if any) from the total rewards.
- Do the same calculation for a flat-rate card with no annual fee.
- The card with the highest net rewards (rewards minus fee) is the best choice for your spending.
Example: You spend $3,600 a year on groceries, $2,400 on gas, $1,800 on dining, and $4,200 on everything else. Card A pays 5% on groceries, 3% on gas, 1% on dining, and 1% on everything else, with a $95 annual fee. Card B pays 2% on all purchases with no annual fee.
Card A: ($3,600 × 0.05) + ($2,400 × 0.03) + ($1,800 × 0.01) + ($4,200 × 0.01) = $180 + $72 + $18 + $42 = $312 in rewards. Minus $95 fee = $217 net.
Card B: ($3,600 + $2,400 + $1,800 + $4,200) × 0.02 = $12,000 × 0.02 = $240 in rewards. No fee = $240 net.
In this example, Card B is worth $23 more per year, even though Card A has higher rewards rates in some categories. The annual fee and your actual spending patterns make the difference.
Rewards redemption: cash back versus points versus travel
Cash back is the simplest form of rewards. You earn a percentage of each purchase back as cash, which you can withdraw or explore to your statement. Cash back has no expiration date and no restrictions on how you use it. This is the most flexible option.
Points are a currency issued by the card company. You earn points for each dollar spent and can redeem them for merchandise, travel, or cash. Points often have an expiration date (usually three to five years of inactivity), and the value of each point varies depending on what you redeem it for. A point might be worth 1 cent if you redeem it for cash, but 1.5 cents if you redeem it for travel. This makes points harder to compare across cards.
Travel rewards are points or miles that you redeem for flights, hotel stays, or rental cars. Travel rewards often have higher point values than cash redemptions, but only if you actually travel. If you never fly or stay in hotels, travel rewards are worthless to you. Travel rewards also come with blackout dates, seat restrictions, and other rules that can make them hard to use.
For most people, cash back is the easiest to understand and use. You know exactly what you are getting, there is no expiration, and you can use it however you want.
Common mistakes to avoid when choosing a rewards card
The biggest mistake is opening a card because of a high rewards rate in one category without checking whether you actually spend money there. A 5% grocery card is not useful if you spend $50 a month on groceries. The second mistake is opening a card with an annual fee without calculating whether your spending will earn enough rewards to cover it.
A third mistake is chasing sign-up bonuses by opening multiple cards in a short time frame. Each new card process creates a hard inquiry on your credit report, which can lower your credit score by a few points. Multiple inquiries in a short time can signal to lenders that you are desperate for credit, which can hurt your score more. Open cards only if you plan to use them.
A fourth mistake is letting rewards expire or go unused. Some cards expire points after a period of inactivity. Some cards close accounts if there is no activity for a year or more, which forfeits any remaining rewards. Read the terms and use your cards occasionally to keep them active.
A fifth mistake is spending more than you normally would just to earn rewards. If you change your habits to hit a spending threshold or earn a bonus, you are spending money you would not have spent otherwise. The rewards do not offset the extra spending.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need good credit to get a rewards card?
Most rewards cards require good to excellent credit (a credit score of 670 or higher). Some card issuers offer rewards cards for people with fair credit, though the rewards rates are usually lower and the annual fee may be higher. Check the card's requirements before you explore.
Can I use multiple rewards cards to maximize earnings?
Yes. Many people use one card for groceries, another for gas, and a third for everything else, based on which card pays the highest rate in each category. This strategy works only if you can keep track of which card to use and pay all the bills on time. If you forget to pay a card or miss a due date, the interest charges and late fees will wipe out any rewards you earned.
What happens to my rewards if I close the card?
This depends on the card issuer. Most issuers let you keep your rewards after you close the card, but some require you to redeem them before closing. A few issuers forfeit rewards if you close the card within a certain time frame (usually one year). Check the terms before you close any card.
Are rewards taxable income?
Cash back and rewards are generally not taxable as income because they are treated as a discount on your purchase, not as a payment. However, sign-up bonuses may be taxable in some cases. The IRS does not have a clear rule on this, so check with a tax professional if you earn a large sign-up bonus.
How do I know if a rewards card is better than paying with cash?
A rewards card is better than cash only if you pay off the full balance every month. If you carry a balance and pay interest, the interest charges will be much higher than any rewards you earn. For example, if you earn 2% cash back but pay 18% interest on a balance, you are losing money. Use a rewards card only if you can pay the bill in full each month.