What "best rewards" means depends on how you spend
There is no single best rewards credit card because the card that pays you the most depends entirely on where your money goes. A card that gives 5% back on groceries and gas will beat a card that gives 2% on everything—but only if you actually buy groceries and gas. A card that offers 3% on dining and travel might be worthless if you never eat out or fly.
The first step is to look at your credit card statements from the last three months and add up what you spent in each category: groceries, gas, restaurants, travel, online shopping, utilities, and everything else. The categories that add up to the most money are where a rewards card can save you the most.
Once you know where your money goes, you can match it to a card's rewards structure. Most cards fall into one of three patterns: cards that pay a flat rate on everything, cards that pay higher rates in specific categories, or cards that let you choose which categories earn bonus rewards.
Key Takeaways
- The best rewards card for you is the one that pays the highest rate in the categories where you spend the most money each month.
- Review three months of statements to find your top spending categories before comparing cards.
- Cards with category bonuses (like 5% on groceries) beat flat-rate cards only if you actually use those categories regularly.
- Annual fees can erase rewards earnings, so calculate whether bonus rewards will cover the fee before you open the account.
- A card with no annual fee and 1.5% cash back on everything beats a premium card with a $95 fee if you don't spend enough to earn back the fee in rewards.
Flat-rate cards versus category-bonus cards
Flat-rate cards pay the same percentage back on every purchase—typically 1.5% to 2% cash back. These cards are straightforward: you spend $100, you earn $1.50 or $2.00. There are no categories to track, no bonus categories that reset, and no spending caps. Flat-rate cards usually have no annual fee.
Flat-rate cards work best if your spending is spread across many different categories, or if you don't want to think about which card to use for each purchase. They also work if you spend very little in any single category—the simplicity often beats the math of chasing bonuses.
Category-bonus cards pay higher rates in specific categories (groceries, gas, restaurants, travel, online shopping) and lower rates on everything else. A common structure is 5% back on groceries and gas, 3% on dining and travel, and 1% on everything else. These cards often charge an annual fee of $95 to $550.
Category cards pay more than flat-rate cards only if you spend enough in the bonus categories to earn back the annual fee and still come out ahead. If a card charges $95 per year and you earn $1,500 in rewards, you net $1,405. But if you only earn $80 in rewards, the card costs you money.
How to calculate whether a rewards card pays for itself
Take your monthly spending in each category and multiply it by the rewards rate the card offers. Do this for all categories, then add them up to get your total monthly rewards. Multiply that by 12 to get your annual rewards.
If the card has an annual fee, subtract the fee from your annual rewards. If the number is positive, the card pays for itself. If it is negative or close to zero, a no-fee card will save you more money.
Here is an example: You spend $400 per month on groceries, $300 on gas, $200 on restaurants, and $1,000 on everything else. A card offering 5% on groceries and gas, 3% on dining, and 1% on everything else would earn you:
- Groceries: $400 × 5% = $20
- Gas: $300 × 5% = $15
- Dining: $200 × 3% = $6
- Everything else: $1,000 × 1% = $10
- Monthly total: $51
- Annual total: $612
If this card has a $95 annual fee, your net reward is $612 − $95 = $517 per year. A flat-rate card paying 1.5% on the same $1,900 monthly spending would earn you $342 per year with no fee. The category card wins by $175.
Cards that let you pick your bonus categories
Some cards let you choose which categories earn bonus rewards each month or quarter, up to a spending cap. For example, you might earn 5% back on up to $1,500 in purchases in a category you choose, then 1% on everything else. Once you hit the $1,500 cap in that category, rewards drop to 1% for the rest of the quarter.
These cards work well if your spending shifts from month to month, or if you want to focus bonuses on whatever you are spending the most on right now. The downside is that you have to actively choose your categories each month—if you forget, you miss the bonus.
The spending caps also matter. If you spend $2,000 per month on groceries but the bonus caps at $1,500, you only earn 5% on the first $1,500 and 1% on the remaining $500. Over a year, that cap costs you money compared to a flat-rate card or a card with no spending cap.
Travel and dining cards with transfer partners
Premium travel and dining cards often let you transfer rewards points to airline and hotel programs instead of taking cash back. These points are sometimes worth more than cash—a point transferred to an airline might be worth 1.5 cents or more, while a cash-back point is worth 1 cent.
However, this only works if you actually use those airline and hotel programs. If you never fly a specific airline or stay at a specific hotel chain, the transfer option is worthless. Also, premium cards almost always charge annual fees of $95 to $550, so you need to spend enough to earn back the fee and still come out ahead.
These cards make sense if you travel regularly on the same airline or hotel chain, and if you have the spending to earn back the annual fee. For most people, a flat-rate card or a category card with no annual fee will save more money.
Annual fees and when they are worth paying
An annual fee is worth paying only if your rewards earnings exceed the fee by a meaningful amount. A $95 fee requires you to earn at least $95 in rewards just to break even—and more if you want the card to actually save you money.
Some cards offer a statement credit or bonus that offsets part of the fee. For example, a card might charge $95 per year but give you a $100 credit toward airline tickets or a $50 credit toward dining. Read the fine print to see what credits are automatic and what you have to do to claim them.
If you open a card and realize after a few months that you are not earning enough to cover the fee, you can close the card. Most issuers will not charge the annual fee again if you close before the anniversary date. Call the card issuer's customer service line and ask about the policy before you close.
How sign-up bonuses affect the math
Many rewards cards offer a sign-up bonus: earn $200 cash back (or 50,000 points) if you spend $3,000 in the first three months. These bonuses can be substantial, but they only count if you would have spent that money anyway.
If you spend $3,000 per month normally, a $3,000 spending requirement is straightforward to hit. If you spend $1,000 per month, you would have to change your behavior to earn the bonus—and that is not a real gain. The bonus only matters if it is money you were going to spend regardless.
Sign-up bonuses can make a card with an annual fee worth opening even if the ongoing rewards do not cover the fee. For example, if a card charges $95 per year but offers a $200 sign-up bonus, you come out $105 ahead in year one even if you earn zero in ongoing rewards. In year two, you would need to earn at least $95 in rewards to break even.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between cash back and points?
Cash back is a percentage of your spending returned as money—1% cash back on $1,000 is $10 deposited to your account. Points are a currency you redeem for rewards like travel or merchandise. Points are sometimes worth more than cash if you transfer them to airline or hotel programs, but they are also harder to use and may expire.
Can I use multiple rewards cards to maximize earnings?
Yes. Many people use one card for groceries and gas, another for restaurants and travel, and a third flat-rate card for everything else. This requires tracking which card to use for each purchase, but it can earn more rewards than a single card. Start with one card and add a second only if you have the discipline to use each card correctly.
Do rewards cards hurt my credit score?
Opening a new card temporarily lowers your score because it creates a hard inquiry and lowers your average account age. Over time, the card raises your score by lowering your credit utilization ratio (the amount you owe divided by your credit limit). The long-term benefit outweighs the short-term dip for most people.
What happens to my rewards if I close the card?
Cash back rewards are usually yours to keep after you close the card. Points rewards vary by issuer—some let you keep points after closing, others cancel them. Check the card's terms before you close to see what happens to your balance.
Is a 2% cash back card better than a 1.5% card?
On $10,000 in annual spending, 2% earns $200 and 1.5% earns $150—a difference of $50. If the 2% card charges a $95 annual fee and the 1.5% card has no fee, the 1.5% card saves you $45. The lower-fee card often wins even if the rewards rate is slightly lower.