Merchant fees are charges that businesses pay to accept your credit card, and those costs often get passed to you
When you swipe or tap a credit card at checkout, the merchant pays a fee to process that transaction. This fee typically goes to the card network (Visa, Mastercard, American Express), the bank that issued your card, and the payment processor handling the transaction. Merchants sometimes pass these costs along by raising prices, charging a surcharge at checkout, or setting minimum purchase amounts for card payments.
Understanding how merchant fees work helps you recognize why some businesses discourage card use, why prices vary between payment methods, and what your rights are when a merchant tries to recover these costs from you.
Key Takeaways
- Merchants pay interchange fees (typically 1.5% to 3.5% of the transaction) to the card issuer and network, plus separate processing fees to their payment processor.
- Visa and Mastercard rules allow merchants to pass fees to customers through surcharges, but only if they disclose the surcharge before checkout and follow specific rules about how much they can charge.
- American Express merchants can charge surcharges in most states, but Discover merchants cannot in many states due to state-level restrictions.
- Merchants cannot charge different prices based on which card brand you use (like charging more for American Express than Visa), though they can offer discounts for cash or debit.
- Rewards cards and premium cards typically trigger higher merchant fees, which is why some small businesses refuse them or set minimum purchase amounts.
How merchant fees break down
A merchant fee is actually three separate charges bundled together. The largest piece is the interchange fee, which goes to your card issuer's bank. Interchange rates vary by card type and merchant category — a restaurant paying for a rewards card might pay 2.5% to 3%, while a grocery store paying for a basic card might pay 1.5% to 2%. Premium cards like American Express Platinum or business rewards cards trigger the highest interchange fees.
The second piece is the card network fee, paid to Visa, Mastercard, American Express, or Discover. This is typically a flat percentage (0.1% to 0.5%) plus a small per-transaction fee. The third piece is the payment processor fee, charged by the company that handles the technical side of the transaction — companies like Square, Stripe, or the merchant's bank. Processor fees vary widely depending on the merchant's contract, but typically range from 0.3% to 1% plus a per-transaction charge.
For a $100 purchase, a merchant might pay $2 to $3.50 total across all three fees. For a $10 purchase, the per-transaction fees become a larger percentage of the sale. This is why small businesses sometimes set minimum purchase amounts for cards.
When merchants can charge you a surcharge
Visa and Mastercard allow merchants to add a surcharge to your bill to recover card processing costs, but only under strict conditions. The merchant must disclose the surcharge before you complete the transaction — typically at the register or on the website before you enter your card number. The surcharge cannot exceed the actual cost the merchant pays to process that specific card type, and in most cases this means the surcharge cannot exceed 3% to 4% of the transaction.
American Express and Discover have different rules. American Express permits surcharges in most states, though a few states (California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Kansas, Maine, Massachusetts, New York, and Oklahoma) restrict or ban them. Discover does not allow merchants to surcharge in any state.
A merchant cannot charge a surcharge for debit cards, and cannot charge different surcharge amounts for different card brands within the same network. If a merchant charges a 3% surcharge for Visa, they must charge 3% for all Visa cards, not more for premium cards.
Discounts for cash and debit are legal
While surcharges are restricted, merchants can offer discounts for paying with cash or debit. A gas station can offer 10 cents off per gallon for cash, or a restaurant can give a 5% discount for debit. These discounts do not count as surcharges and are not subject to the same restrictions.
The practical difference: a surcharge adds a fee to card payments, while a discount reduces the price for non-card payments. Legally, they work the same way (the merchant recovers costs), but the rules treat them differently. If you see "cash discount" or "debit discount" signage, that is legal in all states.
Why rewards cards trigger higher fees
A merchant pays more to accept a rewards card than a basic card because the card issuer is funding your rewards points or cash back. When you earn 2% cash back on a purchase, the merchant's interchange fee is higher to cover that cost. Premium cards like American Express Platinum or business rewards cards can trigger interchange fees of 3% or higher, compared to 1.5% to 2% for a basic card.
This is why some small businesses refuse premium cards or set high minimum purchase amounts for them. A coffee shop accepting a $5 purchase on an American Express Platinum card might pay $0.15 to $0.20 in fees — a significant percentage of a small transaction. Large retailers absorb these costs as part of doing business, but independent merchants sometimes cannot.
You have the right to use any card you want, but merchants also have the right to refuse cards or set minimums. If a merchant refuses your card, you can pay with a different card, debit, or cash.
What you cannot do as a merchant to recover costs
Merchants cannot charge different prices based on which card brand you use. A store cannot charge $100 for a Visa purchase and $103 for an American Express purchase — that violates card network rules. They also cannot require you to pay a surcharge for debit cards, and cannot add a surcharge that exceeds the actual cost they pay to process that card.
Merchants cannot refuse all credit cards, though they can refuse specific card brands (some small businesses refuse American Express due to higher fees). They also cannot add a surcharge to online purchases in some states — California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Kansas, Maine, Massachusetts, New York, and Oklahoma restrict or ban surcharges entirely, whether in-store or online.
If a merchant violates these rules, you can report them to your card issuer or to the card network directly. Your card issuer has a dispute process for unauthorized charges, though a surcharge disclosed before checkout is not unauthorized.
How merchant fees affect card rewards programs
Card networks and issuers fund rewards programs with money from merchant fees. The higher the interchange fee, the more the issuer can afford to pay in rewards. This creates a cycle: merchants pay higher fees for rewards cards, which funds the rewards, which makes those cards more attractive to you, which means more merchants have to accept them and pay the higher fees.
Merchants sometimes try to discourage rewards card use by setting minimum purchase amounts (legal) or surcharging (legal only under specific conditions). Some merchants absorb the cost and raise prices across the board instead — you pay the same whether you use a basic card, rewards card, or cash, and the merchant recovers costs by charging everyone slightly more.
If you use a rewards card frequently, you are benefiting from a system where merchants collectively pay for your rewards. This is not hidden or unfair — it is how the card industry is structured. But it is worth understanding that the 2% cash back you earn comes from fees merchants pay, not from the card issuer's generosity.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a merchant refuse my credit card?
Yes. A merchant can refuse any specific card brand (Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover) as long as they disclose the policy before you start shopping. They cannot refuse all credit cards if they accept any credit cards. If a merchant refuses your card, you can use a different payment method or shop elsewhere.
Is it legal for a gas station to charge more for credit than cash?
Yes, as long as they disclose it clearly before you pump. This is a cash discount, not a surcharge, and is legal in all states. The price posted on the sign is typically the cash price, and credit costs more. Some stations post both prices; others show only the cash price and add the credit charge at the pump.
Why do some restaurants have a minimum purchase for credit cards?
Merchants can set minimum purchase amounts to reduce the impact of per-transaction fees on small sales. A $2 coffee with a $0.30 processing fee is a 15% cost to the merchant, so they set a $10 or $15 minimum for cards. This is legal, though some states restrict it.
Do I pay merchant fees when I use my credit card?
Not directly — the merchant pays the fee, not you. However, merchants often raise prices to cover these costs, so you may pay indirectly through higher prices across the board. Some merchants also add a surcharge at checkout, which is a direct fee you see before you complete the purchase.
Can a merchant charge different surcharges for different card brands?
No. A merchant can charge a surcharge only for the actual cost of processing that card type. They cannot charge 3% for American Express and 2% for Visa, even though American Express costs more. They can refuse American Express entirely, but if they accept it, the surcharge must be the same as for other cards in the same price range.