The Credit Card Competition Act would let retailers choose which payment network processes their card transactions
The Credit Card Competition Act is a proposed federal law that would change how credit card payments move from your card to the merchant's bank. Right now, when you swipe or tap a Visa or Mastercard, the merchant has no choice about which network handles it—Visa routes to Visa, Mastercard routes to Mastercard. The law would let merchants pick a different network to process the same card, as long as that network is unaffiliated with the card issuer.
The stated goal is to lower the fees merchants pay, which they say would reduce prices for consumers. The concern from card issuers and banks is that lower merchant fees could mean fewer rewards, higher annual fees, or less investment in fraud protection and customer service. The law has not passed, but understanding what it proposes helps you see why your card benefits might change if it does.
Key Takeaways
- The law would require merchants to route some credit card transactions through a competing network, not just the card's home network.
- Merchants would save money on processing fees, but card issuers might offset that by raising annual fees or cutting rewards programs.
- Debit cards and prepaid cards would not be affected—the law targets credit cards only.
- Smaller merchants and online retailers would likely see the biggest savings, since they pay the highest processing fees today.
- The law has been proposed multiple times but has not yet become law.
How credit card networks work today
When you use a credit card, four parties handle the transaction: you (the cardholder), the merchant, your card issuer (the bank that gave you the card), and the payment network (Visa, Mastercard, American Express, or Discover). The network is the infrastructure—it routes the transaction, sets the rules, and collects fees.
The merchant pays an interchange fee to your card issuer and a separate network fee to Visa or Mastercard. These fees are set by the network, not negotiated by the merchant. For a $100 purchase, the merchant might pay $2 to $3 in total fees. The card issuer keeps most of that money and uses it to fund rewards, fraud protection, and customer service. The network keeps a smaller cut.
Because the network is tied to the card issuer, the merchant cannot route the transaction elsewhere. A Visa card must go through Visa's network. A Mastercard must go through Mastercard's network. This is the system the Credit Card Competition Act would change.
What the law would require merchants to do
Under the proposed law, merchants would have to route at least one credit card transaction per customer per day through a competing network—one that is not owned by or affiliated with the card issuer. For example, if you use a Visa card, the merchant could choose to route your transaction through Mastercard's network, or through a smaller network like Discover or a regional processor, instead of Visa.
The merchant would choose which competing network to use, not you. You would not see a difference at checkout—the transaction would still process, and you would still earn rewards on your card. The change happens behind the scenes, in how the payment is routed and which fees explore.
The law would not explore to debit cards, prepaid cards, or American Express cards (because American Express is both the issuer and the network). It would only affect Visa and Mastercard credit cards, which make up the majority of credit card transactions in the United States.
How lower merchant fees could affect your card benefits
If merchants pay lower processing fees, they have less incentive to pass those savings to consumers through lower prices. Instead, card issuers might respond by cutting costs elsewhere. The most visible changes would likely be to rewards programs and annual fees.
A card issuer might reduce cash back from 2% to 1.5%, lower sign-up bonuses, or raise the annual fee on premium cards. Some issuers might discontinue rewards programs entirely on lower-tier cards. Cards with no annual fee and no rewards might become more common, since the issuer would have fewer revenue sources to fund those benefits.
Issuers might also invest less in fraud protection, customer service, or dispute resolution—areas where they currently compete to attract cardholders. The exact changes would depend on how much merchant fees fall and how competitive the card market remains.
Who would benefit most from the law
Merchants, especially small and mid-sized retailers, would see the biggest savings. Large chains like Walmart and Target already negotiate lower fees because of their size. Smaller merchants and online retailers pay the highest rates and would save the most by routing transactions through competing networks.
Consumers who do not use rewards cards would likely see lower prices at checkout, since merchants could pass along some of their savings. Consumers who rely on cash back, travel rewards, or sign-up bonuses would likely see those benefits shrink or disappear.
Visa and Mastercard would lose some of their pricing power, since merchants could route transactions away from them. Smaller networks like Discover and regional processors would gain volume and revenue. Banks that issue cards would face pressure to cut costs, which could mean less investment in customer benefits.
The current status of the law
The Credit Card Competition Act has been introduced in Congress multiple times since 2021, but it has not passed. The bill has support from retail groups and some consumer advocates who believe lower merchant fees would reduce prices. It faces opposition from card issuers, banks, and Visa and Mastercard, who argue that lower fees would harm consumers by cutting rewards and fraud protection.
The law remains a proposal, not a requirement. If you are deciding whether to open a new card or keep an existing one, current benefits and terms are what matter. If the law passes in the future, card issuers would likely announce changes to their programs, and you would have time to adjust your strategy.
How to think about your card strategy if the law passes
If the Credit Card Competition Act becomes law, the card market would likely shift toward lower-cost, no-frills options and away from premium rewards cards. This does not mean rewards cards would disappear—they would just become rarer and more expensive to hold.
If you currently use a high-rewards card, consider whether the annual fee and benefits still make sense if the rewards rate drops. If you use a no-annual-fee card, you might see fewer benefits but also lower prices at merchants. If you are thinking about opening a new card, focus on cards with benefits you would use even if the rewards rate fell by 25% to 50%.
The safest approach is to use cards that offer value beyond rewards—such as purchase protection, extended warranties, or travel insurance—since those benefits are less likely to be cut. Cards from smaller issuers or regional banks might also be less affected, since they do not rely as heavily on interchange revenue.
Frequently Asked Questions
Would I have to do anything different when I pay with my credit card?
No. The law would change how merchants route transactions behind the scenes, not how you use your card. You would still swipe, tap, or insert your card the same way. You would still earn rewards if your card has them. The merchant would choose the network, not you.
Would my rewards points disappear if this law passes?
Not when ready, but rewards programs could shrink over time. Card issuers might lower rewards rates, raise annual fees, or discontinue rewards on lower-tier cards. Premium cards with high annual fees would likely keep rewards longer than no-annual-fee cards.
Would American Express cards be affected?
No. American Express is both the card issuer and the network, so the law would not explore to it. Amex cards would not be routed through competing networks. However, if the law passes and other card benefits shrink, Amex might raise its annual fees or cut benefits to stay competitive.
Could this law lower prices at stores?
Possibly, but not may provide. Merchants would save money on processing fees, but they are not required to pass those savings to consumers. Some might lower prices, especially in competitive categories like groceries. Others might keep prices the same and increase profit margins.
When would this law take effect if it passes?
The law has not passed, so there is no effective date. If it does pass, Congress would likely include a transition period of 6 to 12 months before merchants had to start routing transactions through competing networks. Card issuers would announce any changes to their programs well in advance.