Closing an American Express card is straightforward, but the timing and method matter for your credit score

You can close an American Express card by calling the number on the back of your card, visiting your online account, or using the Amex mobile app. The process itself takes minutes. But closing a card affects your credit in ways that may linger for years, so understanding what happens before you close is more useful than understanding how to close.

The main risk is to your credit utilization ratio — the percentage of your total credit limit you are using across all cards. When you close a card, that available credit disappears from the denominator, which can raise your utilization percentage and lower your credit score. A card with a zero balance still counts as available credit while it is open, so closing it removes that benefit even if you never carried a balance on it.

The second consideration is age. American Express reports the age of your accounts to credit bureaus. Closing an older card removes that age from your active accounts, which can lower the average age of your credit history. This effect is smaller than the utilization effect, but it is real.

Key Takeaways

  • Closing an American Express card removes available credit from your account, which can raise your credit utilization ratio and lower your credit score temporarily.
  • If you want to keep the card's age on your credit report, ask American Express to downgrade to a no-annual-fee version instead of closing it.
  • Pay off any remaining balance before you close, and confirm the card shows a zero balance in your Amex account before you call to close.
  • American Express will stop reporting the account to credit bureaus about seven years after you close it, at which point the score impact fades.
  • If you are closing because of an annual fee, downgrading to a different Amex card often takes one phone call and avoids the credit score impact entirely.

When closing makes sense and when downgrading is better

Closing a card makes sense if you have multiple cards from the same issuer and want to simplify, or if you are paying an annual fee that you do not want. But before you close, call American Express and ask whether you can downgrade to a no-annual-fee card instead. Amex often allows this on the same day, and it keeps the account open and reporting to credit bureaus, which protects your credit score.

Downgrading is especially worth doing if the card you are closing is one of your oldest accounts. The longer the account has been open, the more your score benefits from keeping it active. If you have had the card for five years or more, downgrading is almost always better than closing.

Closing makes more sense if the card is newer, if you have other older accounts, or if you straightforward do not want to keep any relationship with American Express. Just go in knowing that your score will dip for a few months, and the effect will be larger if you carry balances on your other cards.

Steps to close your American Express card

Before you close, pay off any balance on the card. Log into your Amex account online or in the app and confirm the balance shows zero. This step matters because American Express will not close a card with an outstanding balance — they will ask you to pay it first.

Once the balance is zero, you have three ways to close:

  1. Call American Express. The number is on the back of your card. Tell them you want to close the account. They may ask why, and they may offer you a retention bonus or a downgrade option. Listen to what they offer, but you are not obligated to accept.
  2. Use your online account. Log in, go to Account Services or Account Settings, and look for a "Close Account" or "Close Card" option. Not all Amex cards offer this online, so if you do not see it, call instead.
  3. Use the Amex mobile app. The app sometimes has a close account option in the same menu as the website. Again, if you do not see it, call.

When you call or submit the request online, American Express will confirm your identity and ask you to confirm that you want to close. They will tell you the account is closed when ready, though it may take a few days for the closure to show in your account.

What happens to your credit after you close

Your credit score will likely drop in the short term because your available credit has decreased. The size of the drop depends on how much credit the card represented. If you are closing a card with a $5,000 limit and you carry $2,000 in balances on other cards, your utilization ratio just jumped from 40% to roughly 67%, which is a meaningful hit.

The drop is temporary. As you pay down balances on your remaining cards, your utilization ratio improves, and your score recovers. Most people see their score return to its previous level within a few months.

American Express will continue to report the closed account to credit bureaus for about seven years. During that time, the account still shows in your credit history and still counts toward the age of your accounts, though the effect weakens over time. After seven years, the account falls off your credit report entirely, and any remaining score impact disappears.

Downgrading instead of closing

If you called American Express and they offered you a downgrade, here is what that means: they convert your current card to a different American Express card with no annual fee. You keep the same account number, the same credit limit, and the same account history. The card itself changes — you may get a new physical card in the mail — but the account never closes.

From a credit perspective, downgrading is almost always better than closing. Your available credit stays the same, your account age stays the same, and nothing changes in your credit report except the card product name. If you are closing because of an annual fee, downgrading solves the problem without the credit score risk.

The tradeoff is that you keep the card, even if you do not use it. Some people find this acceptable because the card is free now. Others prefer to close and be done. That is a personal choice, not a financial one.

Timing and what to do with the physical card

You can close your American Express card at any time. There is no waiting period, no penalty for closing early, and no requirement to keep the card open for a certain length of time. If you just opened it and want to close it, you can.

Once the account is closed, stop using the physical card when ready. You can cut it up, shred it, or throw it away. Do not use it for new purchases — the transaction may be declined, or it may go through and then be reversed, which creates confusion.

If you have set up automatic payments using this card, update those payments to a different card or bank account before you close. American Express will not process new charges on a closed account, so any recurring payments will fail.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will closing my Amex card hurt my credit score?

Yes, temporarily. Your available credit decreases, which raises your credit utilization ratio. The score impact is usually largest in the first month and fades over a few months as you pay down other balances. The effect is smaller if you have multiple cards and larger if you carry high balances elsewhere.

Can I reopen a closed American Express card?

American Express does not reopen closed accounts. If you close a card and change your mind, you would need to open a new account. You would get a new account number and a new card, though American Express may waive the annual fee if you call within a short window of closing.

What if I have a balance I cannot pay off before closing?

American Express will not close the account while a balance is outstanding. You must pay the balance in full first. If you cannot pay it all at once, pay as much as you can, then call to close. They will close the account and you can continue paying the remaining balance on the closed account.

Do I lose my rewards points when I close the card?

No. Your Membership Rewards points stay in your account even after you close the card. You can still redeem them through your Amex account online. Points do not expire as long as your account remains active in any form, though the terms vary by card.

Is downgrading the same as closing?

No. Downgrading converts your card to a different product but keeps the account open and reporting to credit bureaus. Closing ends the account entirely. Downgrading protects your credit score; closing lowers it temporarily.