American Express cards work best if you spend enough to use the rewards and can pay your full balance monthly
American Express cards are not universally better or worse than other credit cards—they fit certain spending patterns and financial habits well, and others poorly. The real question is whether an Amex card matches how you actually spend money and whether you can use its rewards before they expire.
Most Amex cards charge an annual fee, which means you need to earn enough rewards or get enough value from perks to cover that cost. If you carry a balance month to month, the interest you pay will almost certainly exceed any rewards you earn. If you use the card rarely, the annual fee becomes a pure loss.
Amex cards also have a narrower acceptance network than Visa or Mastercard—some smaller merchants, gas stations, and rural locations do not take them. Before you open an Amex card, check whether the places you shop regularly accept it.
Key Takeaways
- American Express cards charge annual fees ranging from $0 to several hundred dollars, so you must earn enough rewards or use enough card perks to justify the cost.
- Amex cards are not accepted everywhere—check whether your regular merchants take American Express before opening an account.
- Amex rewards typically expire after a set period (often three years), so you need to use them or lose them.
- Amex cards often require higher credit scores to open, and the company may deny you even if your score is good if your credit history is thin.
- If you pay interest on your balance, any rewards you earn will be outpaced by the interest charges.
How Amex rewards actually work
American Express cards earn points, miles, or cash back depending on the card. The earning rate varies by card and by category—some cards earn 1 point per dollar on everything, while others earn 3 or 4 points per dollar on specific categories like dining or travel, and 1 point on everything else.
The catch is that Amex points are not the same as cash. You must redeem them for something—a flight, a hotel stay, a statement credit, or a merchandise purchase. Some cards let you transfer points to airline or hotel partners, which can increase their value if you know how to use those programs. Other cards let you convert points directly to cash back at a fixed rate, usually 1 cent per point.
Amex points expire after three years of inactivity on most cards, meaning if you do not use them within that window, they vanish. This is different from some other card programs where points do not expire. If you open a card and then forget about it, your points will disappear.
Annual fees and whether they pay for themselves
Amex cards with no annual fee exist, but most cards that offer strong rewards or travel perks charge $95, $150, $250, or more per year. To know whether a card is worth the fee, you need to do basic math: How much will you spend on this card each year, and how many points will you earn?
A card that charges $95 per year and earns 1 point per dollar on all purchases is worth it only if you spend enough to earn at least $95 in value from those points. If the card earns 1 point per dollar and you can redeem points at 1 cent each, you need to spend at least $9,500 per year just to break even. If you spend less, you lose money.
Some Amex cards offer perks beyond points—statement credits for dining, travel insurance, airport lounge access, or other benefits. These perks have real value only if you actually use them. A $250 annual fee is not worth it for a $200 airline credit if you do not fly, or a $100 dining credit if you never eat at the restaurants that may have access to.
Acceptance and where Amex cards do not work
American Express is accepted at most major retailers, restaurants, and hotels in the United States. However, acceptance is not universal. Gas stations, small local businesses, some online merchants, and rural locations may not take Amex.
If you rely on a single card for all purchases, an Amex-only strategy will create problems. Many people who carry an Amex card also carry a Visa or Mastercard as a backup for places that do not take American Express. This means you are managing two cards instead of one, which adds complexity.
Before opening an Amex card, visit the places where you spend the most money—your regular grocery store, gas station, favorite restaurants, and any online retailers you use frequently—and ask whether they take American Express. If more than a few say no, an Amex card will be frustrating to use.
Credit score and approval requirements
American Express typically requires a credit score of 670 or higher to open most cards, though some premium cards require 700 or above. Even if your score meets the minimum, Amex may deny you if your credit history is too short, if you have recent late payments, or if you have too many recent credit inquiries.
Amex also looks at your income and existing debt. If you have high balances on other cards or a recent bankruptcy, Amex may decline you even if your score is acceptable. The company is more selective than Visa or Mastercard issuers.
If you are denied, you can call the reconsideration line and ask why. Sometimes Amex will approve you if you explain your situation or offer to lower your credit limit request. But there is no may provide, and reapplying when ready after a denial will likely result in another denial.
When an Amex card makes financial sense
An American Express card is a good fit if you spend at least $10,000 to $15,000 per year on the card, pay your balance in full each month, and shop at places that accept Amex. You also need to be willing to track your points and redeem them before they expire.
Amex cards are especially useful if you travel frequently and want to earn airline miles or hotel points. Many Amex cards offer bonus points for travel purchases, and the ability to transfer points to airline partners can make those points worth more than cash back. If you fly once or twice a year and stay in hotels, an Amex travel card can pay for itself through points alone.
Amex cards are also a good choice if you spend heavily in a specific category that earns bonus points—dining, groceries, or gas—and you can redeem those points for something you actually want. If you eat out frequently and a card earns 4 points per dollar at restaurants, the rewards can add up quickly.
When an Amex card is not worth it
Do not open an Amex card if you carry a balance from month to month. The interest you pay will be far larger than any rewards you earn. If you have a history of paying late or missing payments, an Amex card will cost you more in interest and fees than it saves in rewards.
Skip an Amex card if you spend less than $5,000 per year on credit cards in total. The annual fee will consume most or all of your rewards. You will come out ahead with a no-annual-fee card from Visa or Mastercard, even if the rewards rate is lower.
Do not open an Amex card if the places you shop most often do not take American Express. You will end up carrying two cards, which defeats the purpose of having a rewards card. A single card you use everywhere is more valuable than a rewards card you use sometimes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do American Express points expire?
Yes, on most Amex cards. Points expire after three years of inactivity on the account. If you do not use your points within that window, they disappear and you cannot recover them. Some business Amex cards have different expiration policies, so check your card's terms.
Can I use American Express everywhere Visa and Mastercard are accepted?
No. While Amex is widely accepted at major retailers and restaurants, some merchants do not take it. Gas stations, small businesses, and some online retailers may only accept Visa or Mastercard. Always have a backup card if Amex is your primary card.
What is the difference between Amex points and airline miles?
Some Amex cards earn points that you can redeem for cash back or merchandise. Other Amex cards earn airline miles or hotel points directly. Miles and points are usually worth more when transferred to airline or hotel partners than when redeemed for cash, but the value depends on how you travel.
Will I be denied for an American Express card if my credit score is 650?
Likely yes. Most Amex cards require a score of 670 or higher. Even if you reapply later when your score improves, Amex may still deny you if you have recent late payments, high debt, or a thin credit history. Call the reconsideration line after a denial to ask why and whether approval is possible.
Is it worth paying an annual fee for an Amex card?
Only if you spend enough to earn rewards that exceed the fee, or if you use the card's perks like travel credits or lounge access. Do the math: if the card charges $95 and you earn 1 point per dollar redeemable at 1 cent each, you need to spend at least $9,500 per year to break even. If you spend less, a no-fee card is better.