You can pay your Macy's card balance using another credit card, but only through third-party payment services—Macy's does not accept credit cards directly on their own payment site.
When you log into your Macy's card account at macys.com or through the Macy's mobile app, the payment options shown are bank account (checking or savings), debit card, or digital wallet services like Apple Pay or Google Pay. None of these are credit cards. To use a credit card to pay your Macy's bill, you need to route the payment through a separate service that accepts credit card input and then sends the money to Macy's on your behalf.
The most common third-party services for this are Plastiq, Venmo, and Square Cash. Each charges a fee—usually 2% to 3% of the payment amount—because credit card networks charge them to process your card. That fee comes out of your pocket, so you are paying extra to use this method. The trade-off is that you can earn credit card rewards on the payment itself, which may or may not offset the fee depending on your card's rewards rate.
Key Takeaways
- Macy's does not accept credit cards on their official payment portal; you must use a third-party payment service like Plastiq, Venmo, or Square Cash.
- Third-party services charge a fee of 2% to 3% per transaction because they absorb the credit card processing cost.
- You earn rewards on the credit card payment itself, but the fee often outweighs the benefit unless your card offers 3% or higher cash back.
- The payment still goes to Macy's, so it counts toward your bill and your payment history the same way a direct payment does.
- Processing time varies by service but typically takes 1 to 3 business days for the money to reach Macy's account.
How Plastiq Works for Macy's Payments
Plastiq is a bill payment platform that accepts credit cards and sends the money to almost any business, including Macy's. You create a free account, add your credit card, and enter Macy's as the payee. Plastiq will ask for the payment amount and your Macy's account number. The service charges a flat 2.5% fee on the transaction amount.
The payment typically reaches Macy's within 1 to 3 business days. Plastiq sends it as an ACH transfer (electronic bank transfer) from their account to Macy's, so from Macy's perspective it looks like a normal bank payment. Your credit card is charged when ready when you submit the payment through Plastiq, but Macy's may not see the credit for a few days. During that window, make sure you have enough time before your Macy's due date, or the payment may post late.
Plastiq does not charge a monthly fee and does not require a minimum payment amount, so you can use it for any balance, large or small. However, each credit card has a limit on how much you can send per month through Plastiq—typically $5,000 to $10,000 depending on your account history. If you need to pay more, you can split the payment across multiple transactions or wait until the next month's limit resets.
Using Venmo or Square Cash to Pay Macy's
Venmo and Square Cash are peer-to-peer payment apps, meaning they were designed to send money between people, not to businesses. However, both allow you to link a credit card and send money to a bank account. The workaround is to send the payment to your own bank account (if you have one linked to the app), and then transfer it from there to Macy's through their normal payment portal.
This method adds an extra step and delays, so it is less direct than Plastiq. Venmo charges a 3% fee for credit card payments, and Square Cash charges a similar rate. The money sits in your bank account for a day or two before you move it to Macy's, which means you need to plan ahead to avoid a late payment. Neither service is designed for bill payment, so customer support may be limited if something goes wrong.
For most people, Plastiq is the simpler choice because it sends the payment directly to Macy's without the intermediate step. Venmo and Square Cash work, but they require more manual steps and carry the same or higher fees.
Weighing the Fee Against Your Rewards
Before you pay a 2% to 3% fee to use a credit card, calculate whether the rewards you earn will cover it. If your credit card offers 2% cash back on all purchases, and you pay a 2.5% fee, you lose 0.5% on the transaction. If your card offers 1% cash back, you lose 1.5%. The math only works in your favor if your card offers 3% or higher rewards on the payment category.
Some credit cards offer bonus categories—for example, 3% cash back on "payments and purchases" or 5% on rotating categories. Check your card's terms to see if bill payments fall into a bonus category. If they do, and the bonus is 3% or higher, the fee may be worth it. If your card offers 1% or 2% across the board, paying the fee to use a credit card is usually a net loss.
A simpler approach is to pay your Macy's card directly from your bank account or debit card through Macy's official portal. You avoid the fee entirely and still build your payment history. You only use a third-party service if you have a specific reason—such as meeting a credit card minimum spend requirement or earning a sign-up bonus that requires spending within a time window.
What Happens to Your Payment After It Reaches Macy's
Once the third-party service sends the money to Macy's, the payment is treated like any other payment. It posts to your account, reduces your balance, and counts toward your payment history. Macy's does not know or care that the money came through Plastiq or another intermediary—they only see that a payment arrived.
The payment typically posts within 1 to 3 business days of being sent by the third-party service. During that time, your balance still reflects the full amount owed. Make sure you account for this delay when planning your payment, especially if you are close to your due date. If the payment does not post by your due date, Macy's may report a late payment to credit bureaus, even though you sent the money on time.
To be safe, send the payment at least 5 business days before your due date. This gives the third-party service time to process it and Macy's time to receive and post it. If you are cutting it close, contact Macy's customer service to confirm the payment was received and when it will post.
Alternatives to Using a Third-Party Service
If the fee feels too high, you have other options. The simplest is to pay directly from your bank account through Macy's website or app—no fee, no delay, no extra steps. This works if you have a checking or savings account and do not need to earn credit card rewards on the payment.
If you want to use a credit card but do not want to pay a fee, consider whether the purchase itself (not the payment) can be made with a credit card. For example, if you buy something at Macy's with a rewards credit card, you earn rewards on the purchase. Then you pay off the Macy's card from your bank account. This way, you get the rewards benefit without paying a fee on the payment itself.
Another option is to check whether your credit card issuer offers a bill payment service. Some banks allow cardholders to pay bills directly from their credit card account without a third-party intermediary. Contact your credit card company to see if this is available. If it is, there may be no fee, though the service is less common than it used to be.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will paying my Macy's card with a credit card hurt my credit score?
No. The payment itself does not affect your score. What matters is whether the payment posts on time and whether it reduces your balance. As long as the payment reaches Macy's by your due date, it counts as an on-time payment. Your credit utilization (the percentage of your credit limit you are using) may improve once the balance drops, which can help your score.
Can I use a credit card to pay my Macy's bill directly on their website?
No. Macy's payment portal only accepts bank accounts, debit cards, and digital wallets like Apple Pay. To use a credit card, you must route it through a third-party service like Plastiq. Macy's does not accept credit cards directly because of the higher processing costs they would incur.
What if my payment through Plastiq does not post by my due date?
Contact Macy's customer service and provide your Plastiq confirmation number. Ask them to note that the payment was sent on time and to hold off on reporting a late payment while they investigate. Most companies will work with you if you can show proof that you initiated the payment before the important date. In the future, send payments at least 5 business days early to avoid this issue.
Is there a limit to how much I can pay through Plastiq?
Yes. Plastiq limits the amount you can send per month, typically $5,000 to $10,000 depending on your account history and the credit card you use. If you need to pay more, you can split the payment across multiple transactions or send part of it through Plastiq and the rest directly from your bank account through Macy's.
Do I earn rewards on the payment amount or just the purchase amount?
You earn rewards on the payment amount when you use a credit card to pay through a third-party service. The service treats it as a purchase, so your credit card rewards explore. However, the fee you pay is separate and does not earn rewards—it is a cost you absorb.