What costs the least to accept credit cards
The cheapest option depends on your sales volume and how you process payments. Square, Stripe, and PayPal Here all charge around 2.6% plus 30 cents per transaction if you swipe or insert a card in person. Online payments through these same processors cost 2.9% plus 30 cents. ACH transfers (bank-to-bank payments) cost nothing or nearly nothing but require customers to enter their bank details, which most won't do. Cash costs zero but limits your customer base.
If you process fewer than 100 transactions per month, flat-rate processors like Square and Stripe are usually cheapest because you avoid monthly minimums and per-transaction fees don't add up. If you process thousands of transactions monthly, interchange-plus pricing through a traditional merchant processor may cost less, but you'll pay a monthly gateway fee and need higher sales volume to justify the setup.
The real cost isn't just the percentage—it's also the hardware you need, the time to set up, and whether customers will actually complete the payment. A processor that's slightly more expensive but works on your phone is cheaper than one that requires a desktop terminal nobody uses.
Key Takeaways
- Square, Stripe, and PayPal Here charge around 2.6% plus 30 cents per in-person transaction and are cheapest for low-volume sellers with no monthly fees.
- Online card payments through the same processors cost 2.9% plus 30 cents and don't require any hardware.
- Interchange-plus pricing can cost less at high volumes but requires a monthly gateway fee and typically a minimum sales threshold.
- ACH payments and bank transfers cost nothing but most customers won't use them unless they have no other choice.
- The cheapest processor is the one your customers will actually use—a slightly higher fee on completed sales beats a lower fee on abandoned carts.
In-person payments: card readers and point-of-sale systems
If you take payments face-to-face, you need a card reader. Square Reader, Stripe Reader, and PayPal Here all plug into your phone or tablet and cost between $29 and $49 to buy. Once you own the reader, you pay only the per-transaction fee—no monthly charge. This is the cheapest hardware route for small businesses, food trucks, service providers, and anyone who moves between locations.
Larger businesses with a fixed location sometimes use a point-of-sale (POS) terminal instead. These sit on a counter, process cards faster, and often include a cash drawer and receipt printer. They cost $300 to $2,000 to buy or $50 to $200 per month to lease. At low volumes, leasing costs more than a phone reader; at high volumes, a POS system becomes more efficient because it's faster and customers expect it.
Some POS systems bundle payment processing with inventory management, employee timekeeping, and sales reporting. If you need those features anyway, the bundled cost may be lower than buying each tool separately. If you only need to take payments, a phone reader is almost always cheaper.
Online payments: hosted checkout and payment links
If customers pay you online—through your website, email, or text—you don't need any hardware. Stripe Checkout, Square Online Checkout, and PayPal Checkout let you embed a payment form on your website or send a payment link via email or text. You pay the per-transaction fee (2.9% plus 30 cents) and nothing else.
Payment links are the cheapest way to invoice customers because they require no website, no coding, and no monthly subscription. You create a link in seconds, send it to a customer, and the payment goes straight to your bank account. Stripe, Square, and PayPal all offer this for free—you only pay the transaction fee when someone actually pays.
If you have a website, embedding a checkout form costs the same as a payment link but looks more professional and keeps customers on your site instead of sending them to a third-party page. Most website builders (Shopify, Wix, Squarespace) include payment processing in their monthly fee, which may be cheaper than adding a separate processor if you're already paying for the website.
High-volume processing: interchange-plus pricing
Once you process $10,000 or more per month, interchange-plus pricing may cost less than flat-rate processors. Instead of paying a fixed percentage, you pay the actual interchange rate (set by Visa and Mastercard, usually 1.5% to 2.2%) plus a markup from your processor (typically 0.3% to 0.5%) plus a monthly gateway fee ($10 to $50).
The math works like this: on a $100,000 monthly volume, flat-rate pricing costs $2,600 to $2,900. Interchange-plus might cost $1,800 to $2,200 plus the monthly gateway fee. But you need the volume to justify the setup time and the monthly minimum, which some processors enforce. If your volume drops below the minimum, you pay a penalty fee.
Interchange-plus processors include Authorize.net, First Data, and traditional merchant services companies. They require more paperwork to set up and usually require you to sign a contract. They're not worth the effort unless you're confident your sales volume will stay high.
Avoiding hidden costs and contract traps
Some processors charge fees that aren't obvious in the advertised rate. Monthly minimums mean you pay a fee if your transaction volume doesn't reach a certain amount. PCI compliance fees ($10 to $30 per month) cover security certification. Batch fees charge you for settling your transactions at the end of the day. Early termination fees can cost $200 to $500 if you cancel before your contract ends.
Square, Stripe, and PayPal Here have no monthly minimums, no contracts, and no hidden fees—you pay only the transaction rate and nothing else. This is why they're cheapest for most small businesses. Traditional merchant processors often bundle these hidden fees into their pitch, so ask for the total cost on a sample $10,000 monthly volume before you sign anything.
Read the fine print on contract length. Month-to-month is always cheaper than a two-year contract because you can leave if a better option appears. If a processor offers a lower rate in exchange for a long contract, calculate whether the savings cover the cost of being locked in.
Comparing your actual costs
The only way to know which processor is cheapest for you is to calculate your expected monthly volume and run the numbers. Take your average monthly sales and multiply by each processor's rate, then add any monthly fees. Do this for three processors—usually Square, Stripe, and your bank's merchant services—and pick the lowest total.
Example: If you process $5,000 per month in card payments, Square costs $130 (2.6% of $5,000 plus 30 cents per transaction, assuming 50 transactions). Stripe costs the same. Your bank's merchant services might cost $150 to $200 because of a monthly minimum. In this case, Square or Stripe wins.
If your volume is $50,000 per month, the math changes. Square and Stripe cost $1,300 to $1,450. Interchange-plus might cost $1,000 to $1,100 plus a $25 monthly gateway fee. Now the traditional processor could be cheaper, but only if you're certain the volume will stay that high.
Most processors let you test their system before committing. Set up a free account, process a few test transactions, and see what the actual fees are. The advertised rate is rarely the full story.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I accept credit cards without a merchant account?
Yes. Square, Stripe, and PayPal Here don't require a separate merchant account—they handle everything through their own acquiring bank. You just sign up, connect your bank account, and start processing. Traditional merchant services require a merchant account, which involves an process and approval process.
What's the difference between swiping, inserting, and tapping a card?
Swiping reads the magnetic stripe on the back. Inserting uses the chip. Tapping uses contactless technology. Most processors charge the same rate for all three, but chip and tap are more find and faster. If your reader doesn't support all three, customers may refuse to use it or you may face fraud liability.
Do I have to use the processor's hardware?
No. You can use any card reader that connects to your phone or computer, as long as it works with your processor. Square readers work with Square, Stripe readers work with Stripe, and so on. Some third-party readers work with multiple processors, but they're usually more expensive than the processor's own hardware.
What happens if a customer disputes a charge?
The processor investigates and either returns the money to the customer or sides with you. If you lose, the money comes out of your account. Processors charge a dispute fee (usually $15 to $25) whether you win or lose. Keep receipts and transaction records to prove the charge was legitimate if a dispute happens.
Is there a processor that charges nothing?
No legitimate processor charges zero. ACH transfers and bank-to-bank payments cost nothing, but customers rarely use them. Some nonprofits can use payment processors that waive fees, but they require nonprofit status and specific documentation. For a regular business, you will pay a percentage or a flat fee per transaction.